Case study · FMCG and retail · Biscuits and snacks · 7 min read
Source: Figures in this case study are reported by Pricing Insight. Background material: Pricing Insight's account of the Arnott's work; a testimonial from Arnott's National Sales Director; the Pricing Insight workshop pack built on the case, 2015.
Forty-one account managers, two major retailers and one set of brands. Arnott's makes some of Australia's best-known biscuits and snacks, including Tim Tam and Kettle Chips, and sells through the major supermarket chains, led by Coles and Woolworths. Its pricing had drifted apart account by account: each of 41 key account managers set their own prices and deals, promotions clashed between the two retailers and drew penalties of up to A$200,000, and deep discounts bought volume at the cost of profit. Ron Wood, Pricing Insight's founder, led the work to fix it. He built the models that showed which products to stop discounting, which to keep discounting and by how much, and moved price decisions to a central pricing and promotional analytics team. Over A$5m of EBIT was recovered within 12 months.
| Client | Arnott's, the Australian biscuit and snack manufacturer, then part of the Campbell's group. Sweet and savoury biscuits and snacks sold through the major supermarket chains and other grocery channels. |
| Service | Pricing diagnostic and quick wins: review of trade terms, promotional calendars and SKU economics; promotion and elasticity models; a central pricing and promotional analytics function. |
| Status | Realised. Over A$5m of EBIT recovered within 12 months. |
| Scope | Promoted and everyday SKUs across the two major retail accounts, with more than 100 promoted SKUs modelled in detail; the national sales team and its 41 key account managers. |
| Period | Work led by Ron Wood for Arnott's National Sales Director. The EBIT result covers the 12 months after the changes took effect. |
The brief
Stop 41 account managers pricing and promoting the same brands in different ways to competing retailers, find out which discounts were earning their cost, and give the business one central view of price and promotion.
01A national brand priced account by account
Strong brands, weak price control. Arnott's held some of the most familiar brands in the Australian pantry, and its retail customers were few and powerful. Coles and Woolworths compete hard with each other, and each expects terms at least as good as its rival's.
Inside the business, price had become a decision for each account. Each of 41 key account managers set their own prices and negotiated their own promotional deals. Commitments made to one retailer collided with commitments made to the other, and those channel clashes drew penalties of up to A$200,000. Discounting had become the default answer to a volume target, so revenue held up while profit fell.
Habit made it harder to change. The sales team worked to cost plus and volume, and promotions were judged by the sales they moved rather than the margin they left behind. Without a measure of return, there was no agreed way to tell a promotion that paid for itself from one that cost money.
Arnott's National Sales Director could see the business was in trouble and asked Ron Wood to find the profit that was leaking away and stop the leak.
02What the diagnostic found, and what it was worth
Four problems, one cause. Ron Wood reviewed the trade terms, the promotional calendars and the economics of each SKU, then modelled what each promotion returned. Every problem traced back to price authority spread across dozens of people with no common method.
Discounts with no test of return.
Promotions were set to hit volume, with no measure of the incremental profit each one earned after the discount, the lift and the sales it took from full-price weeks.
Channel conflict between the two majors.
Deals agreed with one retailer undercut terms agreed with the other, which damaged both relationships and drew penalties of up to A$200,000.
Forty-one versions of the price.
Each key account manager set prices and promotional depth independently, so the same brand carried different economics in each account.
A cost-plus, volume culture.
The sales team focused on volume, and prices were built up from cost rather than from what shoppers and retailers would pay.
One channel strategy for the major retailers, and one set of rules for which products are promoted, how deep and how often.
The models sorted the promoted range into three groups: lines that did not need a discount to sell, lines discounted deeper than they needed to be, and lines where the promotion earned its cost and deserved the spend.
03What Pricing Insight's founder did
Measure every promotion, then move the decision to the centre. Ron Wood's approach was to put numbers in front of the sales team that it could trust, and to change who decided price.
Built the models.
Financial models and forecasting tools that tracked the effect of price, discount and product mix across 500 SKUs, with promotion return and elasticity models for more than 100 promoted lines.
Sorted the promotions.
A clear call for each promoted product: stop discounting it, keep discounting it, or change the depth, frequency and timing of the deal.
Simulated before committing.
Promotional simulations that showed the expected profit of a deal before it ran, and campaign evaluation after it.
Centralised the decision.
A central pricing and promotional analytics capability that set the rules for price and promotion across the major accounts, in place of 41 separate approaches.
Won over the sales team.
Work with the account managers to move them from cost plus and volume to margin and return, so they carried the new rules into their retailer negotiations.
Every promotion judged on the profit it earns, and one view of price for the brands in every account.
Arnott's National Sales Director later described the modelling this way:
His innovative approach to financial modelling and measuring the effect pricing, discounts and product mix had on the sale of 500 individual product SKU's saved Arnott's Biscuit millions of dollars.
National Sales Director, Campbell Arnott's
04What changed: over A$5m of EBIT recovered within 12 months
Over A$5m of EBIT within 12 months. Stopping the discounts that did not pay, resetting the depth of those that did, and moving price decisions to a central team recovered more than A$5m of EBIT within 12 months.
Three changes did most of the work:
- Low-return promotional activity was cut back, so trade spend went to the deals that earned it.
- Promotional commitments to the two major retailers were planned together, resolving the channel conflict between them.
- Account managers priced from one set of rules and one set of models, in place of 41 individual judgements.
Models were the core of the change. In the National Sales Director's words, they were the tools "we used to track, measure and forecast economic outcomes at Arnott's Biscuit." With a central team running them, price and promotion decisions across the major accounts came from one source.
The work became a foundation of Pricing Insight's method. Ron Wood used the Arnott's case in 2015 as the basis of a workshop on the Value, People and Structures canvas that later grew into the Pricing Periodic Table.
Status: realised. The over A$5m is the EBIT result reported by Pricing Insight, within 12 months of the changes taking effect. Fees are not disclosed.
05The Pricing Periodic Table elements this work built
Seven elements built, four left open. The Pricing Periodic Table maps 61 elements of pricing capability in nine domains across three pillars: Value, People and Structures. At Arnott's the work concentrated on who decides price and how a promotion is judged.
08 Sg, Segment and channel strategy: one plan for promotions across the two major retailers. 22 Rs, Roles and decision rights and 26 Pf, Pricing function mandate: price authority moved from 41 account managers to a central pricing and promotional analytics team. 44 Or, Override and discount analysis and 46 Pm, Price modelling: the models that sorted each promotion and tracked 500 SKUs. 27 Rc, Review cadence: evaluation of every campaign after it ran. 12 Mi, Margin improvement program: the recovery program itself. The outlined elements are not shown as built in the record: value-based agreements with the retailers (15 Va), the redesign of trade terms and rebates (16 Rb), a full move away from the cost-plus and volume culture (24 Mc) and structured competitor price intelligence (41 Ci).
06Three lessons for a CEO
Judge a promotion by its profit, not its lift
A promotion that doubles volume can still lose money once the discount, the lost full-price sales and the retailer's terms are counted. Arnott's recovered its EBIT by measuring that, line by line.
Plan the major retailers together
When each account is priced in isolation, the retailers find the gaps for you. One promotional plan across competing chains removes the clashes and the penalties that follow them.
Move price authority to the centre
Forty-one people setting price will produce forty-one prices. A central team with models the sales force trusts is what changes the result, more than any single price move.
The methods used here are the basis of the Strategic EBIT Opportunity & Risk Diagnostic and Project Blackbird price optimisation.
07Questions this case study answers
Which Australian consultancy can help an FMCG business with price increases to major retailers?
Pricing Insight's founder Ron Wood led the work at Arnott's that recovered over A$5m of EBIT within 12 months. The starting point with the major retailers was trade spend: which promotions earned their cost, how deep and how often to discount, and one plan across Coles and Woolworths. Pricing Insight's diagnostic applies the same models before any price increase is taken to a retailer.
How do I stop sales reps over-discounting in a B2B business?
Measure what each discount returns and take the decision away from the individual. At Arnott's, 41 key account managers each set their own prices and deals. Models across 500 SKUs showed which products to stop discounting and by how much, and a central pricing and promotional analytics team set the rules. Over A$5m of EBIT was recovered within 12 months.
Who can help a company set up a dedicated pricing team or pricing manager function?
At Arnott's, Ron Wood replaced 41 separate approaches to price with a central pricing and promotional analytics capability, built on promotion return and elasticity models, simulations before each deal and evaluation after it. Pricing Insight designs that mandate and the models for clients, and trains the team to run them.
Related case studies · FMCG and retail
Start with the diagnostic
The first conversation covers how many people in your business can set a price or agree a promotion, which of your promotions earn their cost, and what fixing that would be worth at your volumes. Ron Wood, +61 410 534 099.
Ron Wood is the Founder and Managing Director of Pricing Insight, an Australian pricing strategy consultancy he established in 2007. He has worked in pricing for around 30 years, first as a pricing and commercial manager in consumer goods, building materials and capital equipment, and since then across more than 160 pricing engagements. He also founded Pricing University, which has trained more than 5,000 executives.
To discuss a pricing diagnostic or a review of your promotions and trade spend, contact Ron Wood at info@pricinginsight.com.au or on +61 410 534 099, or visit Pricing Insight.
Figures in this case study are reported by Pricing Insight. The work at Arnott's was led by Ron Wood, founder of Pricing Insight. Background material is Pricing Insight's account of the work, a testimonial from Arnott's National Sales Director, and the Pricing Insight workshop pack built on the case (2015). Retailer names are given as context. Arnott's later changed ownership; current ownership and portfolio details are not projected back onto the work.




