Case study · Capital equipment · Commercial vehicles and dealer networks · 8 min read
Source: Pricing Insight engagement records. Company and brand facts from Mercedes-Benz Trucks Australia, Daimler Truck Australia Pacific and Interbrand. The engagement was designed to educate and open a dialogue, not to deliver a financial result, and no financial result is claimed.
One of the world's most valuable brands, sold by dealers who called it a commodity. Mercedes-Benz Commercial Vehicles sold its trucks and vans in Australia through independent dealers who owned their own businesses and set their own stock. Two habits ran against head office. Dealer principals told head office the brand had become a commodity, and bought lower-priced, non-genuine parts to protect their own margins. And because parts came free into store, with head office paying the freight from its parts warehouse at Laverton in Melbourne, dealers held little stock and relied on fast, expensive freight to reach workshops around the country. Senior management engaged Pricing Insight to work with around 50 dealer principals, representing every dealer in the network, at the annual commercial vehicles dealer conference: a 90-minute keynote on the value of pricing, then a full-day workshop the following day, in two streams. The program was an early stage of a change program, built to educate, inform and open a discussion. Dealers rated the sessions highly valuable, and the discussion that followed led head office to review its dealer terms and change its pricing architecture.
| Client | Mercedes-Benz Commercial Vehicles, the truck and van division of Mercedes-Benz Australia/Pacific, Mulgrave, Victoria. Importer and distributor of Mercedes-Benz trucks and vans, sold, serviced and supported through a national network of independently owned dealers. |
| Commissioned by | Commercial Vehicles senior management. |
| Service | Keynote and customised value-based pricing workshop, delivered at the annual dealer conference. |
| Status | Capability built. Head office then reviewed its dealer terms and changed its pricing architecture. |
| Audience | Around 50 dealer principals, representing every dealer in the network. |
| Scope | A 90-minute keynote, then a full-day workshop for groups of dealers in two streams: new vehicles, and aftermarket (service and parts). |
The brief
Educate every dealer on the value of pricing, show dealer principals the pricing power the brand gives them, and open the discussion on what comes next.
01A premium brand, an independent network and a built-in conflict
A national importer selling through dealers it does not own. Mercedes-Benz Commercial Vehicles imported and distributed Mercedes-Benz trucks and vans in Australia from its head office in Mulgrave, Victoria, and sold, serviced and supplied parts through a national network of authorised dealers. Most of that network is independently owned and operated. Mercedes-Benz has ranked among the ten most valuable brands in the world in Interbrand's Best Global Brands.
Two businesses with one customer and different objectives. Head office earns on the vehicle it imports and on the genuine parts it supplies to the network, and it carries the brand. The dealer principal earns on the vehicle margin, on workshop labour and on the parts the workshop fits, and funds the dealership's own stock, staff and premises. The owner of the truck or van judges both on one thing: how long the vehicle is off the road. Dealers push for lower prices from head office as a matter of course, because every dollar off their buy price is a dollar of their margin. That conflict is built into the model, and it made conversations between head office and its dealers about price, parts and stock hard to hold.
Three problems sat inside it.
A premium brand described as a commodity.
Dealer principals told head office that Mercedes-Benz had become a commodity and that customers bought on price. A dealer who sells one of the world's most valuable brands as a commodity gives away the price difference the brand earns.
Lower-priced parts in place of genuine parts.
To lift their own parts margins, dealers sourced lower-priced, non-genuine parts where they could. Each substitution moved margin from head office's parts business to a third-party supplier, and gave up the fit and warranty a genuine part carries when fitted at an authorised dealer.
Free freight in place of dealer stock.
Dealers ordered parts from the Mercedes-Benz parts warehouse at Laverton in Melbourne, and the parts came free into store: head office paid the freight. Holding stock tied up a dealer's capital, while running lean cost the dealer nothing, so dealers held little and relied on fast freight, often by air, which costs many times more per kilogram than planned replenishment by road.
The third problem sat in the contract, not in dealer behaviour. The terms gave each dealer a sound reason to do what made the network as a whole more expensive.
02What the keynote and workshop brought into the open
Dealer principals had more pricing power than they thought. The commodity claim described how vehicles and parts were being sold, not how operators valued them. The value of service and support, including genuine parts, trained technicians and the speed of a repair, was not being priced: an operator losing revenue for each day a truck is off the road values a same-day repair far above its labour rate. Dealers negotiated with head office for a lower buy price and with customers by discount, and in both cases started from price rather than value. And nothing in the dealer terms asked dealers to hold the stock their service levels required, so head office funded the network's parts availability through its freight bill.
Six priorities followed.
Sell the brand on what it is worth to the operator.
Uptime, running cost, resale value and the support behind the vehicle, stated in the operator's own dollars.
Price new vehicles on cost of ownership.
Quote from the value of the truck or van in the operator's application rather than from a competitor's discount.
Price service and parts on what downtime costs.
A fast repair and a part on the shelf are worth more to an operator than the labour hours and the list price suggest.
Sell genuine parts on fit and warranty.
Show the customer what a genuine part buys, so the dealer sells the difference rather than discounting to close it.
Write stocking commitments into dealer terms.
Terms that state the stock a dealer holds to meet its service levels.
Freight terms that charge for urgency, so free freight no longer stands in for dealer inventory.
03What Pricing Insight did
A keynote to the whole network, then a working day with the principals. Senior management commissioned the program and set the audience: the principals who own and run the dealerships. Pricing Insight built it around the principals' own business, so that each concept was applied to a decision a principal makes.
Opened with a 90-minute keynote to every dealer.
Why price is the strongest profit lever a dealership holds, what a premium brand is worth when it is sold on value, and what it costs when it is sold on price.
Ran a full-day workshop the following day.
Run for groups of dealers, applying value-based pricing to the decisions a principal makes: how to quote a new truck or van, how to price a workshop hour, which parts to stock and which to buy.
Stream one: new vehicles.
What a truck or van is worth in the operator's application, including payload, fuel use, service intervals, resale value and uptime, and how to quote from that value rather than from a competitor's discount.
Stream two: aftermarket, service and parts.
What a genuine part, a trained technician and a fast repair are worth to the operator, what lower-priced parts give up, and the full cost of a lean parts shelf, including the share the dealer terms placed on head office.
Recommended a change to dealer terms.
Training alone would not change behaviour that the contract rewarded. Pricing Insight recommended that head office restructure its dealer contracts and terms so that free freight could no longer stand in for dealer inventory and become a cost head office could not sustain.
Dealers who sell the brand, the service and the genuine part on value, and dealer terms that support it.
04What changed: a shared starting point and a review of dealer terms
The keynote and workshop were well received, and dealers rated them highly valuable in the feedback collected at the end of the program.
The program met its objective. It was not designed to produce a financial result: Pricing Insight was engaged to educate, inform and raise awareness, and to give management and dealers an agenda for change that they would carry forward themselves.
Head office gained a basis for a different conversation with its network. Discussions between head office and dealers about price, parts sourcing and stock had been difficult and often conflicted, because each side started from the cost it wanted the other to carry. Value-based pricing gave both a common starting point: what the operator values and will pay for, and the pricing power the Mercedes-Benz brand and support give the dealer. A principal who sees that pricing power has less reason to buy on price from a third party, and more reason to sell on value to the customer.
The discussion continued after the conference. Mercedes-Benz management took the observations and recommendations into its own planning, and then into talks with the dealer group on a more effective set of commercial terms. Head office reviewed its dealer terms and changed its pricing architecture, addressing the cause of the stocking problem rather than its symptoms.
Status: capability built. Objective: education, awareness and an agenda for change, which the program met. No financial measure was set, by design, and no change in parts stock, freight cost, genuine parts share or margin is claimed. The review of dealer terms and the change to pricing architecture are reported as actions head office took after the program; their financial effect was not measured by Pricing Insight. Dealer names and comments are not disclosed. Fees are not disclosed.
05The Pricing Periodic Table elements this work built
Six elements built, four identified for the dealer terms. The Pricing Periodic Table maps 61 elements of pricing capability in nine domains across three pillars: Value, People and Structures. The keynote and workshop built the Value and People elements; the review of dealer terms that followed bears on the Structures.
10 Pp, Pricing power and 02 Df, Differentiation: the answer to the commodity claim, putting a figure on what the brand, the vehicle and the support are worth to the operator. 29 Vs, Value selling and 04 Sv, Service value: the method to quote new vehicles, workshop labour and genuine parts on that value. 28 Cc, Commercial capability and training: the keynote and workshop themselves. 25 Ch, Change readiness: the shared agenda that management and dealers carried into their discussion of terms. The outlined elements are where that discussion pointed: dealer terms that state what each side commits, including the stock a dealer holds (15 Va); urgent freight priced as the service it is (53 Sx); parts availability (05 Dr); and the split of margin and cost between head office and its independent dealers (08 Sg). Head office's change to its pricing architecture sits in the table's Price Architecture domain.
06Three lessons for a CEO
Test the commodity claim against the brand
When the people who sell a premium brand describe it as a commodity, the claim usually describes how it is sold. One of the world's most valuable brands was being quoted on price by its own dealers.
Read the contract for the behaviour it pays for
Free-into-store freight made low stock the rational choice for each dealer and an expense for head office. Training cannot hold against terms that reward the opposite behaviour, which is why head office followed the program with a review of its dealer terms.
Start the change with a shared understanding
A keynote to every dealer, followed by a working day with the principals, gave both sides the same starting point and an agenda they took into their own discussion of terms. Not every step in a change program produces a figure; this one produced the conversation the later steps depended on.
07Questions this case study answers
How can dealers stop selling a premium brand as a commodity?
Start by measuring what the brand, the vehicle and the service behind it are worth to the operator, in uptime, running cost and resale value, and quote from that value. At Mercedes-Benz Commercial Vehicles, dealer principals described one of the world's most valuable brands as a commodity. Pricing Insight gave a keynote to every dealer at the annual conference and ran a full-day workshop the following day, showing principals the pricing power they held in new vehicles and in aftermarket service and parts.
Why do dealers under-stock parts, and who pays for it?
When parts are supplied free into store, the manufacturer pays the freight and the dealer pays nothing for urgent supply. Holding stock then costs the dealer capital, while running lean costs it nothing, so parts travel by fast and expensive freight instead of sitting on the shelf. The cost lands on the manufacturer, and the fix sits in the dealer terms: stocking commitments and freight terms that charge for urgency.
How should a manufacturer handle the conflict between head office and independent dealers over price?
The conflict is built into the model: dealers earn more when they buy for less, and head office earns more when they buy genuine parts at its price. A shared method, value-based pricing taught to every dealer at the head office's own conference, gives both sides a common starting point in what the operator values. At Mercedes-Benz Commercial Vehicles, that shared starting point led to further discussion within management and then with the dealer group on a more effective set of commercial terms.
Related case studies · Capital equipment
A keynote and workshop for your network
The first conversation covers your dealer or distributor network, where price and terms create friction between head office and the channel, and how a keynote and workshop would be built around your business. Ron Wood, +61 410 534 099.
Ron Wood is the Founder and Managing Director of Pricing Insight, an Australian pricing strategy consultancy he established in 2007. He has worked in pricing for around 30 years, first as a pricing and commercial manager in consumer goods, building materials and capital equipment, and since then across more than 160 pricing engagements. He also founded Pricing University, which has trained more than 5,000 executives.
To discuss a keynote or workshop for your team or network, contact Ron Wood at info@pricinginsight.com.au or on +61 410 534 099, or visit Pricing Insight.
Engagement details are from Pricing Insight's records of the program. Company facts from Mercedes-Benz Trucks Australia (Service and Parts) and Daimler Truck Australia Pacific (Mercedes-Benz Trucks), reviewed 9 November 2026. Brand ranking from Interbrand, Best Global Brands. Mercedes-Benz commercial vehicles are now distributed in Australia by Daimler Truck Australia Pacific (trucks and buses) and Mercedes-Benz Vans Australia. No financial result is claimed. Dealer names and comments are not disclosed. Fees are not disclosed. Photography: Mercedes-Benz Trucks Australia.
