Discounting and deal control · 19 min read
Branch and state discounts have drifted apart
One national price structure, applied the same way in every branch, gives customers one price and the sales team one story. Branch managers stop competing with each other and start competing with the market.
Source: Pricing Insight diagnostic issues register, drawn from staff surveys in building products, rural supplies, hardware retail and distribution, security hardware, medical products, office technology and coatings; clients are described by sector and not named. The price spread is from an anonymised trade distributor and the narrowed range is projected. The Staples result is realised. The worked example in section 03 is illustrative.
- Price the same product the same way everywhere for the same type of customer on the same terms.
- Allow real differences within a set band, and require a reason code for any price outside it.
- The fix is one national list less an earned discount, override reporting by person, product and customer, and a quote desk for complex jobs: elements 49, 51, 54, 44 and 40 of the Pricing Periodic Table, with four more that hold them in place.
Branch and state price variation is not one register issue but six that arrive together: override culture, blanket discounting, discount creep, no discount authority matrix, no price corridor and price lists that are not maintained. Two are among the ten issues raised most often in our diagnostics, and two were raised in every business we have measured. Discounting to close the sale, the issue raised most often of all, has its own page.
This page sets out how branches drift apart, what the diagnostic evidence shows, what the spread is worth, the six features of a national structure that holds, the elements that decide the problem, and the decisions, designs and routines that bring every branch back onto one list. It is written for the chief executive, the CFO and the sales director of a multi-branch business.
The question this page answers
Why do our branches quote three prices for one product code, what is that spread costing us, and how do we bring every branch onto one national structure without losing the customers who matter?
01Branches that kept their own price lists now compete with each other, and the lowest price wins.
Mergers and acquisitions have left many networks with branches that kept their own price lists, special prices and discount habits. Customers who buy across states compare notes, and national accounts expect one price. Depending on who they call, they can be quoted three different prices for one product code.
Six signs. Special prices have no end date or owner. Customers know which branch will give the better deal. Discount tiers have no entry or exit criteria, so very different accounts sit on the same tier. Each division keeps its own pricing control on a spreadsheet. Price matches are given on a customer's word, without a sighted quote. Temporary promotions have become permanent.
Left alone, customers learn which branch gives the better deal and buy there. In one timber group, one branch needed only a 16 per cent margin on framing pine while another in the same state needed 32 per cent, and the same builder could buy from both a day apart. The lowest branch price becomes the national price.
Special prices set years ago never expire unless someone retires them, and each one becomes a precedent other customers ask for. That is the decision that is hard to reverse: a price given at one branch in one year is live until the business ends it, and the customer treats the ending as a price rise.
Recovery is done one account at a time. Bringing branches back into line means moving customers to new tiers and managing the conversations that follow, and with a cap on how far any account moves in one step, it is done without losing the customers who matter.
Branch drift turns a national business into a set of local competitors sharing a brand and a cost base. Every point the lowest branch gives away is a point every other branch will be asked to give.
02Six register issues make up this problem, and two of them were raised in every business we have measured.
In Pricing Insight's cross-client issues register, drawn from staff surveys across eight businesses, this problem is made up of six issues. Override culture, where sales or senior leaders change prices without governance, is among the ten issues raised most often and was raised in seven of the eight businesses. Price list maintenance, where legacy prices persist and cost increases are not recovered, is also among the ten raised most often and was raised in every business. Blanket discounting, the same discount given regardless of what each customer earns, was raised in every business as well.
Three further issues sit beside them. No price corridor, meaning no floor, target or ceiling, was raised in seven of the eight businesses. No discount authority matrix was raised in six. Discount creep, where temporary becomes permanent, was raised in five. Discounting to close the sale, the most frequently raised issue in the register, is the behaviour these six make possible; it is treated on its own page.
Staff at a security hardware manufacturer described four businesses, four lists and four discount structures left behind by an acquisition. Staff at a building products group with six business units described regional rates set without input from the branches, and project prices extended by a rep so that a customer kept the same price through price rises.
As a result of the acquisition, there are effectively 4 different business and therefore list prices and discounts structures.
National Pricing Team - not enough input from branches to set regional rates which correspond with market rates.
Project pricing can be extended by rep / sales manager. This can 'go under the radar' and customers could have same price for extended periods through price rises.Staff comments from Pricing Insight diagnostic surveys, security hardware manufacturer and building products group, reproduced as written
Three of the six issues sit in price architecture, the domain with the weakest scores in our diagnostics, so the businesses we measure are weakest at the structures that would stop branches drifting.
At a hardware distributor, staff described a tier structure in which a large customer on the top tier could pay the same price as a much smaller customer two tiers down, and the discount for one tier varied widely between product groups. Their request: tier every product across every level, so that a customer's tier meant the same thing on every line.
03The spread between branches is worth more than any single discount.
Two numbers. Consistent tiers recover margin that leaks between branches and protect the price position in every region. In one trade distributor, about 220 customers paid anywhere from about A$51 to A$103 for the same item: the highest price was twice the lowest. Under a single national structure, the projected range narrowed to about A$55 to A$86, with the median unchanged at about A$76. The customers paying least moved up a little, the customers paying most came down to the published ceiling, and most did not move at all.
Now a network. Take a distributor with 20 branches and A$80 million of revenue at a 25 per cent gross margin. Twelve months of invoices show that a quarter of revenue, A$20 million, is sold to customers who pay 8 per cent below the price their tier would set. Moving those accounts halfway back, a 4 per cent step with the cap set there, recovers 4 per cent of A$20 million, which is A$800,000 a year of gross profit with no change in volume, a 16 per cent lift on the A$5 million those accounts earn today. Illustrative; not a client result.
Volume risk is smaller than branch managers expect. A 4 per cent rise at a 25 per cent gross margin lifts the gross profit on each A$100 of sales from A$25 to A$29, so profit holds even if volume falls by about 14 per cent (25 divided by 29 is 0.86).
Pull twelve months of invoices for the twenty products that carry most of your margin and, for each product and customer tier, list the price paid by branch. The spread between the highest and lowest branch price for the same tier, multiplied by the volume sold below the median, is the number to put on the table. Anything wider than freight and service can explain is drift.
04A national structure that holds has six features, and every branch can see all of them.
Ron Wood's view, set out in B2B Pricing Insight (Pricing Insight, 2026): "Price the same product the same way everywhere for the same type of customer on the same terms. Allow real differences within a set band, and require a reason code for any price outside it."
One national list price per product, less a single discount that deepens with customer size.
No customer pays more than the published trade-counter price, so the ceiling is visible to everyone. Every branch, division and acquired business works from the same list, and the legacy lists are switched off, not left running beside it.
Three or four tiers with written entry and exit criteria, re-tiered each year.
Each tier is earned on the last twelve months of spend, with criteria written so that two account managers would put the same customer on the same tier. A customer who falls below the threshold moves down at the annual review; one who grows moves up.
Special prices with an expiry date and an owner.
Every project, contract and special price is recorded with its owner and its end date, and at that date it is renewed on evidence or it lapses. The book puts it plainly: "a price without an end date is a price for ever".
Overrides reported each month by product, by person and by customer, and reviewed each quarter.
Every price outside the band carries a reason code. The monthly report goes to the sales director and the branch managers; the Pricing Council's quarterly review decides whether the band is wrong or the behaviour is.
A small expert quote desk for complex jobs, with service levels and a log of winning prices.
Routine work is priced by the structure. Large, unusual or multi-branch jobs go to a desk that answers inside the day and logs the price that won and the price that lost.
Price matches only against a sighted quote, and only for something in return.
The rule is a sighted competitor quote or invoice, a match, offer or walk grid that tells branch staff which response fits which product, and something received in return: volume, range, terms or a forecast.
Branch managers will say their market is different, and sometimes it is. The band holds the differences in freight, competition and service. The structure removes only the difference whose reason is who the customer called first.
05Nine elements of pricing capability decide whether branches hold one price.
Mapped to the Pricing Periodic Table, branch and state drift turns on nine of the 61 elements across seven domains, four of them in price architecture and systems and controls. None needs new data, because twelve months of invoices already hold every price paid. Each needs a decision, a loaded rule or a report someone reads.
Elements this problem turns on. The Pricing Periodic Table has 61 elements in nine domains across Value, People and Structures; it is the map of B2B Pricing Insight.
| Element | Domain | What it looks like when it holds |
|---|---|---|
| 13Py Pricing policy and consistency | Pricing Strategy | The same product priced the same way for the same customer type in every branch, with the permitted band written down |
| 49Lp List price alignment | Price Architecture | One national list price per product that every branch and acquired business works from, with no legacy list running beside it |
| 51Dt Discount structure and tiers | Price Architecture | Three or four tiers earned by spend, with written entry and exit criteria, re-tiered each year on the last twelve months of trading |
| 54Co Price corridors and exceptions | Price Architecture | Real differences allowed within a set band; any price outside it carries a reason code and a named approver |
| 17Ar Agreement register | Customer Agreements | Every special, project and contract price recorded with an owner and an end date |
| 61Da Discount authority and controls | Systems & Controls | Approval limits loaded in the quoting and invoicing system, covering counter overrides and direct loads as well as quotes |
| 44Or Override and discount analysis | Analysis & Processes | Overrides reported each month by person, product and customer, and the branch-to-branch spread on like items reported each quarter |
| 40Dd Deal desk and negotiation governance | Market, Sales & Negotiation | Complex quotes priced centrally and fast, with service levels and a log of the prices that won |
| 24Mc Margin culture | Management Alignment | Branch managers who work inside the structure because leaders back it, and do not treat the counter override as the way to win a sale |
06Three kinds of work bring the branches back, and the order matters.
Strategy is decisions the chief executive writes down. Structure is designs the CFO and the pricing manager load into the system. Operations is routines that run on a calendar and produce a report. The order matters, because tiers loaded before anyone has decided how far a branch may differ will be overridden at the first difficult quote.
Strategy
Decisions for the chief executive
Three decisions, two pages, made with the invoice data the business already holds.
Decide that one national list applies to every branch and every acquired business.
One list price per product, one discount structure, and a date by which every legacy list is switched off, written down and signed. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →
Decide how far a branch may differ, and write the band down.
Freight, local competition and service justify real differences. Decide the width of the band for each product group, and that anything outside it carries a reason code and a named approver. EBITDA Improvement Program →
Decide the cap on how far any account moves in one step.
A cap protects the customers who matter and makes the conversation one a branch manager can have. It also sets the pace of recovery. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →
Structure
Designs for the CFO and the pricing manager
Three designs. Each replaces a branch judgement with a rule the system enforces everywhere the same way.
Rebuild the tiers.
One national list less earned tiers, written entry and exit criteria, and a schedule to retire dormant special prices, published so that every branch applies them the same way. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →
Give every special price an owner and an end date.
Load every project, contract and special price into one register with the person responsible and the date it lapses. At one cabinet and architectural hardware distributor described in B2B Pricing Insight, about 64,000 tender lines in one state had no sales in twelve months and every one was still a live price; the recommendation gave each an end date, and the book records it as a recommendation with no reported result yet. EBITDA Improvement Program →
Load the authority ladder, including counter overrides and direct loads.
The branch inside the band; the state manager a little below it; the sales director with the pricing manager further down; the quote desk, with a written case, beyond that. Loaded so that an unapproved price cannot be invoiced from any screen. EBITDA Improvement Program →
Operations
Routines for the sales director and the pricing team
Three routines, each on a calendar with one owner and a report someone reads.
Compare prices across branches.
Twelve months of invoices: what the same type of customer paid for the same item, branch by branch and seller by seller. Run it first as a diagnostic, then each quarter, so drift is seen in the quarter it starts. Strategic EBIT Opportunity & Risk Diagnostic →
Move the accounts.
Each branch manager receives the accounts to move and the conversation to have, with match rules that need a sighted quote and something in return. Train the conversation on the branch's own accounts before the letters go out, largest exceptions first. Negotiation Training & Value-Based Selling →
Report overrides monthly and review them at the Pricing Council each quarter.
Every price outside the band, by person, product and customer, with its reason code, goes to the sales director monthly and to the Pricing Council quarterly. The council owns the band and the tiers and settles the disputes that would otherwise be settled at the counter. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →
07Businesses that brought their branches onto one structure, and what came of it.
Corporate Express Australia, later Staples, replaced cost-plus pricing and 60 price lists with one national structure, and A$6.8 million of EBITDA was realised within 12 months of implementation. That figure is realised. At Allegion, an acquisition had left four price lists for three merged businesses; Project Blackbird modelled A$3.6 million of annual EBIT from one price architecture in August 2020, and new list prices for 5,300 SKUs went live from November 2020. That figure is modelled, not realised.
At Stramit, where branches carried years of customer-specific net prices, large and small customers sat on the same rates and overrides were entered without a second signature, a diagnostic identified an A$4 million to A$7.5 million annual EBIT opportunity. At Tradelink, a plumbing supplies distributor, the diagnostic identified an A$10.8 million annualised margin opportunity, and the business built capability first, training its whole sales force. Both figures are identified, sized in the diagnostic and not yet measured in the accounts.
Two consumer businesses show the same problem between account managers rather than branches. Super Retail Group reduced ad hoc discounting by up to 50 per cent across four retail brands with shared markdown rules and discount governance. Arnott's moved price decisions from 41 account managers to one team, repriced promotions and discounts, and recovered over A$5 million of EBIT within 12 months. Both results are realised, and in both the gain came from one set of rules applied the same way by everyone.
At a New Zealand rural supplies co-operative described in B2B Pricing Insight, branch staff overrode prices at the counter so often they had a name for it. The recommended fix was a four-tier rule set and a rule that gave discount authority only to staff who could show they understood mark-up and margin. Neither rule has a reported result yet.
Each result is labelled. Realised means measured against a finance-agreed baseline after the change. Projected means modelled before it. Identified means sized in a diagnostic and not yet acted on. The labels matter more than the numbers.
08Questions a chief executive asks about this problem
- What did the same type of customer pay for the same item across our branches last year?
- Which ten customers and ten products carry the largest overrides, and why?
- Of our last ten price matches, how many had a sighted competitor quote and something received in return?
- List every way a price can be set or changed without approval, including direct loads and counter overrides.
- How many special prices have no end date?
Should branches have any pricing freedom?
Yes, within a set band. Real differences in freight, competition or service can justify a different price, but anything outside the band needs a reason code and an approver.
How do you stop price matching on a customer's word?
Require a sighted quote or invoice before any match, and something in return for it. A match, offer or walk grid tells branch staff which response fits which product.
What happens to customers whose prices rise under a national structure?
Moves are capped so no account changes too far in one step, and each branch manager is given the accounts to move and the conversation to have. Most customers see a modest change, and the published trade-counter price is the ceiling for everyone.
Why not let each state set its own prices to match its own market?
Because customers do not buy by state. National accounts and builders working across borders compare prices between branches, and the lowest branch price becomes the price they ask every branch for. Real regional differences belong inside the band, written down, not in a separate price list each state keeps on a spreadsheet.
How long does it take to bring branches back into line?
It depends on how many accounts sit outside the band and how far the cap allows each to move in a step. The analysis is quick, because twelve months of invoices already hold every price paid; the account moves run on the business's own price-review calendar, largest exceptions first.
09How Pricing Insight treats it
The starting point is the business's own invoices, branch by branch, not a template. Recommendations rest on the client's own transaction data, results are measured against a margin baseline agreed with the client's finance team and reported as realised, modelled or identified, and Ron Wood leads each engagement from the first meeting to handover.
Diagnose
We map twelve months of invoices against the price each customer's tier would set, by branch, seller and product, and list every special price with its owner and end date or the absence of one. The output is a sized register of branch drift, with the accounts to move. Strategic EBIT Opportunity & Risk Diagnostic →
Optimise
We design the national list, the earned tiers, the band and the cap, price the range to value and pricing power line by line where the data supports it, and specify the authority ladder and reason codes for the quoting system. EBITDA Improvement Program →
Transform
We give each branch manager the accounts to move and the conversation to have, train the match, offer or walk rules on their own accounts, and stand up the override report, the quarterly review and the quote desk. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →
Results on this problem
How far apart are your branches on the same products?
The first conversation covers where your branches set prices today, how many lists and special prices are live, and what twelve months of invoices would need to show. Ron Wood, +61 410 534 099.
Further reading
Related problems
Ron Wood is the Founder and Managing Director of Pricing Insight, an Australian pricing strategy consultancy he established in 2007. He has worked in pricing for around 30 years, first as a pricing and commercial manager in consumer goods, building materials and capital equipment, and since then across more than 160 pricing engagements in Australia, New Zealand, South East Asia, India, the United States and the United Kingdom. He is the author of B2B Pricing Insight and the Pricing Periodic Table, and founded Pricing University, which has trained more than 5,000 executives.
To discuss how this applies to your business, contact Ron Wood at info@pricinginsight.com.au or on +61 410 534 099, or visit Pricing Insight.
Diagnostic findings are from Pricing Insight's cross-client issues register of staff survey comments and technique scores; they describe how often an issue was raised, not its dollar size. Businesses in the register are described by sector and not named; quotations are reproduced as written. Figure 1 is from an anonymised trade distributor and the narrowed range is projected, not realised. The worked example in section 03 is illustrative. Staples, Super Retail Group and Arnott's results are realised; Allegion is modelled; Stramit and Tradelink are identified, as stated on the linked case-study pages. The timber group margins, the hardware tender lines and the rural co-operative recommendation are from B2B Pricing Insight (Pricing Insight, 2026) and carry the status given there, as do the elements of the Pricing Periodic Table.
