Home / Problems we solve

Price setting and price architecture · 19 min read

Setting list prices for a new product range

A launch is the one moment a business sets a price without negotiating down from an earlier one. Priced from value, a new range earns its margin every year it sells.

Sevenof the eight businesses in Pricing Insight's pricing diagnostics raised launch prices set at cost plus the standard margin. Cost-plus for the whole range was raised in every one.
A$25Extra price per unit when the 'best' level of a range is priced to the value it adds (A$145) instead of by an even step (A$120). Illustrative; not a client result.
$4.1mIncremental EBITDA realised at King Living after its price architecture was aligned with customer value. Realised result, published on this site.

Source: Pricing Insight diagnostic issues register, drawn from staff surveys in building products, rural supplies, hardware retail and distribution, security hardware, medical products, office technology and coatings. Clients are described by sector and not named. The good-better-best arithmetic is illustrative. The King Living figure is from the published case study.

In short
  • Price new products from customer value before launch, not from cost, the nearest competitor or the old product they replace.
  • No product launches until five questions are answered: the alternative, the worth above it, the share kept, the structure and the seller's line.
  • Review the price at 3, 6 and 12 months after launch, before buying habits form, against a corridor agreed before launch (elements 14 Np New product pricing, 3 Vq Value quantification and 54 Co Price corridors and exceptions).

Launch prices set at cost plus the standard margin were raised in seven of the eight businesses in our diagnostics, in every sector except hardware retail. Cost-plus as the default method for the whole range, the habit a launch inherits, was raised in all eight. Staff described new prices set from old products, a flat target margin or a cost sheet, not from what the product is worth to the customer.

This page sets out why a launch price is the hardest price to change, what the diagnostic evidence shows, what good-better-best steps are worth when they follow value, the elements of the Pricing Periodic Table that decide the problem, and the decisions, designs and routines that fix it. It is written for the chief executive, the CFO and the sales director.

The question this page answers

How should we set the list price for a new product range, and how do we know before launch whether the price is too high or too low?

01A launch price set from cost is a price the business lives with for years.

Product cycles are shorter and ranges larger, so businesses launch more products and services each year with less time to price them. Customers compare new products with online alternatives from the first day, and competitors copy successful products and drive prices down. Under that pressure the product team reaches for the method it already has: the cost sheet and the standard margin.

Five signs mark a business with this problem. New products launch at cost plus the usual margin. New services carry a flat target margin, and nobody can say whether it is too high or too low; in one office-technology company reported in B2B Pricing Insight, managed IT services carried a flat 40 per cent target margin and nobody could say which way it was wrong. Nobody has asked target customers what the product is worth to them. There is no agreed floor, so discounts start in the first week. Launch prices are not reviewed once buying habits form.

Left alone, the price does one of two things. A product priced below its value earns less for its whole life and pulls down the range above it, because customers read the new product as the reference for everything near it. A product priced above its value stalls and is discounted to move, which teaches the market that the launch price was never real.

Of all the prices a business sets, the launch price is the hardest to reverse. The first price customers see becomes their reference, and raising it later is negotiated like a price rise, with the same objections and the same risk to the account. Our register records the consequence in one line: once a launch price is set it rarely gets recovered. Repositioning a mispriced product means a relaunch, new collateral and customer conversations, usually at a lower margin than a correct launch price would have earned.

Why it matters

A launch is the one price decision that does not start from a customer's existing price. Set from value, it earns its margin every year the product sells. Set from cost, it hands the difference to the customer every year after, and the business negotiates uphill to get any of it back.

02Launch prices set at cost plus the standard margin were raised in seven of the eight businesses we have measured.

In Pricing Insight's pricing diagnostics, new products priced at cost plus the standard margin were raised in seven of the eight businesses: a building products group with six business units, a rural supplies co-operative, a hardware distributor, a security hardware manufacturer, a medical products company, an office technology company and a coatings manufacturer. Only the hardware retail co-operative did not raise it. Two issues sit behind this one: cost-plus as the default pricing method and weak competitor intelligence, each raised in every business, which together leave the product team guessing at the alternative the customer will compare the new range with.

Four related issues sit beside them. Segmentation weakness, raised in every business, means one launch price goes to customers who would pay very different amounts. A commodity mindset, also raised in every business, means staff price a differentiated new product as though it were interchangeable with the one it beats. Weak value articulation, raised in six of the eight, means sellers cannot explain why the new product is worth more and discount it in the first month. Channel conflict, raised in every business, means a new range reaches the market at different net prices through different channels before anyone has decided what the price should be.

They define pricing on new products, based on old products, not based on the market conditions.
We set pricing at cost plus $$$. We should set it at what the product is worth in the market.
Stop using a 'cost plus' approach and sell at the highest possible market price.
Staff comments from Pricing Insight diagnostic surveys, reproduced as written, from an office technology company and two units of a building products group

Pattern matters more than any one comment. The people who set launch prices described the method as an inheritance: the old product's price, a head office transfer price, the supplier's recommended retail price or the margin the budget assumed. None of those measures what the product is worth to the customer. The weakest capability scores in our diagnostics sit in price architecture and pricing strategy, the two domains a launch price draws on.

One business, sharpest

At a security hardware manufacturer, sales staff asked for a clear pricing structure for a powder-coated range and for the lowest margin they could accept on a project before walking away. Both requests describe a corridor that should have been set before the range launched. Without it, every project price for the new range was negotiated from scratch.

03Steps that follow value, not even increments, decide what a range earns.

Two numbers. Launch pricing compounds: each year the product sells, the margin set at launch is earned again. Good, better and best steps show the effect. Where 'better' adds A$40 of value above 'good' and 'best' adds A$160, even price steps of A$10 hand most of that value to the customer. Priced by even steps, 'best' sells at A$120, so the business keeps A$20 of the A$160 of extra value, one eighth, and gives the customer the other A$140. Steps that follow value price 'better' at A$113 and 'best' at A$145. The business keeps A$45 of the A$160, a little over a quarter, and the customer still keeps A$115 of the extra value, about A$2.50 of net gain for every extra dollar paid.

A$0A$40A$80A$120A$160A$100A$100GoodA$110A$113BetterA$120A$145BestEven stepsValue steps
Figure 1. Price of each level: even steps against value steps (A$). 'Better' adds A$40 of value above 'good'; 'best' adds A$160. Even steps price 'best' at A$120; steps that follow value price it at A$145. Illustrative; not a client result.

On volume the difference is plain. If the 'best' level sells 10,000 units a year, the A$25 gap between A$120 and A$145 is A$250,000 of gross margin a year, every year the product sells. Over a five-year product life that is A$1.25 million at the same volume, before any price increase. Both figures are illustrative, not client results, and both assume the value steps hold volume.

A new service priced at a flat target margin is right only by accident. If the customer's alternative is doing the work in-house at a known cost, the service is worth the saving plus the risk removed, and a cost-sheet margin has no relationship to either number. The test before launch is the five questions in the book: the customer's next-best alternative and its cost, the worth above it in dollars, the share of that worth the business keeps, the structure of list, band, floor and channel prices, and the line the seller will use.

The CFO's test

Take the last three product launches. For each, pull the launch list price, the average invoice price in the first quarter and the average invoice price in the most recent quarter, and beside them write what the customer's alternative cost at launch. If the invoice price fell and nobody decided it should, the launch price was never held. If the gap between invoice price and the alternative is wider than the value the product adds, the price was set from cost.

04What good looks like: a checkpoint, a corridor and steps that follow value.

Six things, in order. A checkpoint in product development, a price set from the next-best alternative, a corridor agreed before launch, good-better-best steps that follow value, sellers briefed before the first call and a review after launch. None needs a system the business does not already have.

A pricing checkpoint sits in product development.

No product or service launches until its price and the value case behind it are approved. Passing the checkpoint needs the answers to the five launch questions, written down and signed by the pricing owner.

The price is set from the next-best alternative and the extra value above it.

Start with what the customer would buy if the new product did not exist, and what that costs them: the rival product, the old product, doing without or doing the work themselves. Put the extra value above that alternative in dollars, from the customer's own figures. The price sits between the alternative and the alternative plus the value.

Floor, target and ceiling prices by segment and channel are agreed before launch.

A corridor for each customer segment and channel, loaded before the first quote. Prices inside it need no approval; prices below the floor need a named approver and a reason code. The same product reaches each channel at a net price that does not undercut the others.

Good, better and best steps follow the value each level adds.

Where 'best' adds four times the value of 'better', its price step is larger, not the same. Steps that follow value keep a similar share of the extra value at each level, so the customer who wants more pays for more.

Sellers are briefed before launch on the value story, the target price, the floor and the give-get rules.

The seller's line is the fifth launch question: what sellers say, not what they discount. Before the first call, every seller has the value case in the customer's terms, the target price, the floor and the give-get list. Promotions on a premium product are limited in its first months.

The price is reviewed at 3, 6 and 12 months after launch.

Realised invoice prices are compared with the corridor at each review, by segment and channel, and adjusted before buying habits form. A product selling at list with no resistance means the price was set too low.

05The elements of pricing capability that decide this problem.

Mapped to the Pricing Periodic Table, pricing a new range is decided by ten of the 61 elements, in five domains. None needs new data. Each needs a decision made before launch, a structure loaded before the first quote or a review on the calendar.

ValuePeopleStructures
Customer Value
Vp
Df
Vq
Sv
Dr
Pricing Strategy
Ws
Po
Sg
Ot
Pp
Cm
Mi
Py
Np
Customer Agreements
Va
Rb
Ar
Tp
Rn
Management Alignment
Ed
Ca
Rs
Pn
Mc
Ch
Pricing Team
Pf
Rc
Cc
Market, Sales & Negotiation
Vs
Vt
Pb
Nu
In
Ng
Wa
Cn
Bt
Pv
Ka
Dd
Analysis & Processes
Ci
Wl
Pi
Or
Pr
Pm
Ps
Kp
Price Architecture
Lp
Md
Dt
Rl
Sx
Co
Tn
Bc
Systems & Controls
Dq
Qt
Is
Pl
Da

Elements this problem turns on. The Pricing Periodic Table has 61 elements in nine domains across Value, People and Structures; it is the map of B2B Pricing Insight.

ElementDomainWhat it looks like when it holds
14Np New product pricingPricing StrategyLaunch prices set from value, with a checkpoint in product development and a review after launch
3Vq Value quantificationCustomer ValueThe worth above the next-best alternative, in dollars, from the customer's own figures
2Df DifferentiationCustomer ValueUnique lines priced from value, never matched to look-alikes or to the product they replace
8Sg Segment and channel strategyPricing StrategyA launch price for each customer segment and channel, so the same product does not undercut itself
41Ci Market price intelligenceAnalysis & ProcessesThe price of the customer's alternative known before launch, by segment and region
50Md Price-setting methodPrice ArchitectureOne written method for setting a new price, from the alternative and the value above it
52Rl Price relativities and volume breaksPrice ArchitectureSteps between good, better and best set by the value each adds, and volume breaks that earn their discount
53Sx Charges for services and extrasPrice ArchitectureIncluded, chargeable and on-request services decided at launch and written into the price list
54Co Price corridors and exceptionsPrice ArchitectureFloor, target and ceiling by segment and channel, loaded before the first quote, with exceptions logged
27Rc Review cadencePricing TeamLaunch prices reviewed at 3, 6 and 12 months against the corridor, with a named owner for each review

06How it is treated: three kinds of work, in order.

Strategy is a set of decisions the chief executive makes and writes down. Structure is a set of designs the CFO and the pricing manager load into the system. Operations is a set of routines that run on a calendar. The order matters, because a corridor loaded before anyone has established what the product is worth is a corridor set at cost.

1

Strategy

Decisions for the chief executive

Three decisions, two pages, made before the next launch.

Establish what it is worth.

Value discovery with target customers, the price of the next-best alternative, and the worth above it in the customer's own terms. Negotiation Training & Value-Based Selling →

Decide the share of value the business keeps.

Between the alternative and the alternative plus the value, the price is a choice. Keep a smaller share where the customer must change behaviour to adopt the product, more where it removes a cost the customer already pays. Write the share down, so the next launch uses the same rule. Strategic EBIT Opportunity & Risk Diagnostic →

Put the pricing checkpoint in product development.

No product or service launches until the five launch questions are answered and the pricing owner has signed the price. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →

The chief executive's question

Of the products we launched in the past two years, which one was priced from what a customer told us it was worth, and who signed that price?

2

Structure

Designs for the CFO and the pricing manager

Three designs. Each replaces a launch-meeting judgement with a rule the system holds.

Set the corridor and the structure.

Floor, target and ceiling prices by segment and channel, good-better-best steps, and which services are included or charged. Loaded before the first quote, so the launch price is the price the system offers. Strategic EBIT Opportunity & Risk Diagnostic →

Set the steps between levels from value, line by line.

Where a range has several levels, finishes or sizes, the relativities between them are modelled from the value each adds and the alternative at each level, not from an even increment. The same model prices the extras and the service options. EBITDA Improvement Program →

Give every channel one net price that does not undercut another.

A new range reaches distributors, direct accounts and online customers at net prices set from one structure, with channel margins that reflect the work each channel does, so channel conflict is designed out before launch. EBITDA Improvement Program →

The CFO's question

For our last launch, what was the floor, who could go below it, and what did the invoice price do in the first quarter?

3

Operations

Routines for the sales director and the pricing team

Three routines, each on a calendar with one owner.

Brief sellers before launch.

The value story, the target price, the floor and the give-get rules, taught on the new range itself, with the objections sellers will hear and the line to use for each. Negotiation Training & Value-Based Selling →

Review after launch.

Realised prices compared with the corridor at 3, 6 and 12 months, by segment and channel, and adjusted before habits form. Prices below the floor go to the sales director with a reason code. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →

Keep the alternative's price current.

Sellers log competitor and alternative prices for the new range by segment and region, reported each quarter beside the realised price. When the alternative moves, the corridor is reviewed, not the discount. Pricing Masterclass (12-Week Program) →

The sales director's question

Of the sellers quoting our newest range, how many can say what the customer's alternative costs and what our product saves them?

07Businesses that acted, and what came of it.

At King Living, a furniture retailer and manufacturer, Pricing Insight's advice aligned the price architecture with customer value. King Living implemented the advice and generated $4.1 million in incremental EBITDA. That figure is realised, and the case is published on this site. At SIMCRO, an animal health and veterinary devices business owned by private equity, we built a customer-value-led pricing strategy through customer value discovery, price optimisation and customer agreement design. That is a capability-built result; no financial figure is published.

At Allegion, a door hardware business, an acquisition left four price lists for one market. Project Blackbird modelled A$3.6 million of annual EBIT from one price architecture in August 2020, and new list prices for 5,300 SKUs went live from November 2020. That figure is modelled, not realised. At Corporate Express Australia, later Staples, cost-plus pricing and 60 price lists were replaced by one national structure, and A$6.8 million of EBITDA was realised within 12 months.

Two building products businesses show the diagnostic side. At Oliveri Solutions, a kitchen and bathroom products business, a 2020 diagnostic found cost-plus pricing and identified a A$2.5 million to A$4.5 million EBIT opportunity. At Stramit, a roll-formed steel business, a 2020 diagnostic found pricing from cost and identified a A$4 million to A$7.5 million annual EBIT opportunity. Both figures are identified, not realised.

Reading the results

Each result is labelled. Realised means measured against a finance-agreed baseline after the change. Projected means modelled before it. Identified means sized in a diagnostic and not yet acted on. The labels matter more than the numbers.

08Questions a chief executive asks about this problem

Five questions to ask on Monday
  1. How did we set the price of our last launch, and has it held at 3, 6 and 12 months?
  2. Which new service launched in the past two years was priced from the customer's alternative, and who approved the price?
  3. Is there a documented method for setting the price of a new product?
  4. Which parts of our range do customers treat as interchangeable, and which do they not?
  5. Do the steps between our good, better and best levels follow the value each adds?

How should a new B2B product be priced?

Start with the customer's next-best alternative and its price, then quantify the extra value your product delivers above it and decide how much of that value to keep. Cost sets the floor, not the price.

What is the launch test?

Five questions answered before launch: what the customer's alternative is, what your product is worth above it, how much of that difference you keep, the price structure across list, band, floor and channel, and the line the seller will use. The price is then reviewed at 3, 6 and 12 months.

How should subscriptions and new services be priced?

Against the cost of doing the work in-house or buying it piece by piece, with a clear statement of what is included in each level, what is extra and when the price is reviewed. A flat target margin on a service is right only by accident, because it has no relationship to what the customer saves.

Should a new product be priced off the product it replaces?

No. The old product's price was set for a different offer, often by cost-plus, and usually carries years of negotiated discounts. Use it only as one of the customer's alternatives. If the new product delivers more, the gap between the two prices should reflect the extra value, and the old product's price may need to fall or the old product withdrawn.

What happens when a competitor launches a cheaper copy?

Decide the response before it happens, as a rule in the pricing strategy: match, trade, hold or walk away, by segment. A copy at a lower price changes the customer's alternative, so the corridor is reviewed, not the discount. Where the product is differentiated in substance, the value case holds the price; where it is not, the business decides whether to compete on price in that segment or to leave it.

09How Pricing Insight treats it

The starting point is the business's own launch history, invoice file and customers, not a template.

1

Diagnose

We pull the last three launches from the invoice file and compare the launch list price, the first-quarter invoice price and the current invoice price against the customer's alternative. We interview target customers for the range about to launch and put the value above the alternative in dollars. Strategic EBIT Opportunity & Risk Diagnostic →

2

Optimise

We set the launch price from the alternative and the value above it, design the corridor by segment and channel, model the good-better-best relativities and the service charges line by line, and set one net price structure across channels. We write the launch test into the product development process. EBITDA Improvement Program →

3

Transform

We brief the sellers on the new range using their own accounts, with the value story, the target price, the floor and the give-get rules, stand up the 3, 6 and 12 month review against the corridor, and hand the launch test to the pricing owner. Value-Based Culture & Transformation →

Results on this problem

What will customers compare your new range with, and at what price?

The first conversation covers the range you are about to launch, how the price is being set today, and what the last three launches did in the invoice file. Ron Wood, +61 410 534 099.

Contact Pricing Insight

Further reading

Related problems

About the author

Ron Wood is the Founder and Managing Director of Pricing Insight, an Australian pricing strategy consultancy he established in 2007. He has worked in pricing for around 30 years, first as a pricing and commercial manager in consumer goods, building materials and capital equipment, and since then across more than 160 pricing engagements in Australia, New Zealand, South East Asia, India, the United States and the United Kingdom. He is the author of B2B Pricing Insight and the Pricing Periodic Table, and founded Pricing University, which has trained more than 5,000 executives.

To discuss how this applies to your business, contact Ron Wood at info@pricinginsight.com.au or on +61 410 534 099, or visit Pricing Insight.

Diagnostic findings are from Pricing Insight's cross-client issues register of staff survey comments and technique scores; they describe how often an issue was raised, not its dollar size. Businesses are described by sector and not named; quotations are reproduced as written, with obvious typing errors corrected. Case results are labelled realised, modelled, identified or capability built as stated on the linked case-study pages: King Living $4.1 million incremental EBITDA (realised); Staples A$6.8 million EBITDA within 12 months (realised); Allegion A$3.6 million annual EBIT (modelled); Oliveri Solutions A$2.5 million to A$4.5 million EBIT and Stramit A$4 million to A$7.5 million annual EBIT (identified); SIMCRO (capability built). The good-better-best arithmetic and the 10,000-unit example are illustrative and not client results. The launch test, the office technology example in section 01 and the elements are from B2B Pricing Insight (Pricing Insight, 2026).

Let’s work together

Whether you're ready to optimise your pricing or want to explore what's possible, we'd love to hear from you.

Follow us on
Pricing Insight

Thank you

Thanks for reaching out. We will get back to you soon.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Pricing Insight