How to Make Tesla’s Pricing Strategy Work For Your Business

Ron Wood, Pricing Insight
How to Make Tesla’s Pricing Strategy Work For Your BusinessHow to Make Tesla’s Pricing Strategy Work For Your Business

White paper · Transform · 20 min read

A$3mEBIT gain within 12 months at Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific, from a A$100k loss, after a single dealing desk replaced discounts given at will; realised
A$5m+EBIT recovered within 12 months at Arnott’s after pricing was centralised and untracked promotional promises were stopped; realised
A$3.8mLower end of the A$3.8m to A$6.5m EBIT gain identified at Allegion, where prices could be changed with no financial rationale or approval; identified

Sources: Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific, Arnott’s and Allegion case studies published on pricinginsight.com. Hyster-Yale and Arnott’s are realised results; Allegion is an identified opportunity, not a result. All are as reported by Pricing Insight, not independently audited, and none is a benchmark for another business. Figures about Tesla are public reporting.

Elon Musk has shared an email on Tesla’s pricing strategy with the world for a very specific and clever reason. We can go into the strategy behind sharing this email some other time, but there are important points to note from his email that you can apply to your own business. It is important, however, to appreciate the nuance to his email and the relevant business model and industry dynamics at play. The thinking and the context behind the message are crucial to note. Here is Elon Musk’s email to all Tesla dealerships.

The question this paper answers

How does a chief executive stop discounts that have no rationale, without removing the flexibility to price for value?

Key takeaways

  • The CEO should take an active interest in pricing strategy and outcomes.
  • Discounts can have a role when they have a clear rationale and are controlled.
  • Protecting new-car prices can support resale value, brand loyalty and customer lifetime value.
  • Negotiation cannot fix a marketing value communication problem.

Four Pricing Insight clients show the same mechanism in business-to-business markets. Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific, Arnott’s, Allegion and Devro each appear below in the same six-part form: the problem and what it put at risk, why it was hard to fix, what Pricing Insight did, the outcome with its status, the benefit to the client, and the Pricing Periodic Table elements the work built.

01One email to a dealer network sets out a complete discount policy

First, I’d like to congratulate you on an excellent quarter so far! This is likely to be the best ever in Tesla history thanks in large part to your efforts.

That said, it is absolutely vital that we adhere to the no-negotiation and no-discount policy that has been true since we first started taking orders 10 years ago. This is fundamental to our integrity and we maintain this policy even through the terrible depths of the great recession of 2008/2009.

It is fine to have a discount on cars that have been floor models, or used in test drives or were damaged before delivery. All we are doing there is assigning an accurate price to the vehicle. However, there can never, and I mean never, be a discount on a new car coming out of the factory in pristine condition, where there is no underlying rationale.

This is why I always pay full price when I buy a car and the same applies to my family, friends and celebrities, no matter how famous or influential.

The acid test is that if you can’t explain to a customer who paid full price why another customer didn’t without being embarrassed, then it is not right. We either win in a way that is fair and right or we lose with our honour intact and accept the consequences.

Also, I have asked our finance group to make sure that we only count a car as delivered in a quarter it if it is actually delivered. Title transfer alone is irrelevant.

Finance will also be reporting every case of a car sold for less than list price, along with the reasoning for doing so which I will be reviewing personally.

Although this appears to be limited to a small number of cases worldwide, it needs to be zero cases.

I’m sorry for the draconian language as I am super grateful for your hard work, there is nothing that matters more than our integrity as a company. Customers need to know with absolute certainty they can always trust Tesla to do the right thing.

Thanks, Elon

In this one email we have the basis for a pricing strategy framework that you can use to guide your own pricing strategy.

Five rules sit inside it. Each one can be written into the pricing policy of a manufacturer or distributor that sells through reps, branches or dealers, and each maps to an element of pricing capability a business can build and measure.

What the email saysThe rule a B2B business can writePeriodic Table element
No negotiation and no discount on a new car with no underlying rationaleEvery discount carries a stated reason from an approved list; no reason, no discount13 Py Pricing policy
Floor models, test-drive cars and damaged stock may be discountedDiscounts are allowed where the product or the deal is different: ageing stock, damaged goods, a measurable volume or term commitment51 Dt Discount structure and tiers
The founder, family, friends and celebrities pay full priceNo customer is exempt because of who they are; authority to discount sits with the role, not the relationship61 Da Discount authority and controls
The acid test: explain to a full-price customer why another paid lessA price difference is defensible only if it can be explained by volume, cost to serve, term or value delivered54 Co Price corridors and exceptions
Finance reports every sale below list, with the reason, for personal reviewA monthly override report by product, person and customer, owned by finance and read by the chief executive44 Or Override and discount analysis

Exhibit 1. The email as a pricing policy. The left column paraphrases the email as published; the right two columns are Pricing Insight’s translation for a business-to-business seller.

02Pricing strategy and outcomes belong with the chief executive

Pricing strategy and tactics are a primary concern of the CEO and Founder of a $30 billion company, a figure as publicly reported when this paper was first written. Jeff Immelt, CEO of General Electric, also reviews pricing outcomes. There are a limited number of progressive CEOs in Australia who will take such an active and personal interest in pricing strategy and outcomes. In our view, any CEO who leaves pricing strategy discussions and decision making to the discretion of the Sales or Marketing Director has a death wish.

The CEO stops the problem early

Most companies we see with margin erosion problems have discounting behaviour that is out of control. It is not isolated to one or two rogue sales reps but endemic from the ground up to the Sales Director. The discounting behaviour often goes hand in hand with a cultural belief that the company’s business has been commoditised.

The Tesla pricing policy is built on a fundamentally sound strategy of pursuing customer and marketplace integrity. Discounting new cars affects the resale value of cars and so devalues the installed base of cars already in the market. By protecting the new car price, Musk is also protecting the investments of early adopters who bought Tesla cars.

This then builds brand loyalty and goes a long way to ensuring that those Tesla owners will also make their next car purchase a Tesla. By forgoing a few sales generated by discounting, Tesla is playing a longer game looking at Lifetime Value of a Customer who may well buy one, two, or three Tesla vehicles over the next 10 years.

A forklift business shows the same dealer economics in a business-to-business market. Its dealers made their money on hire, service and parts, so a discount on a new machine looked sensible to the channel and cost the manufacturer its margin. What fixed it was the step Musk describes: one point of control that saw every price below list, with a reason attached.

01

Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific

Forklift wholesaler · A$100k EBIT loss to A$3m gain within 12 months · Realised

Client and problemHyster-Yale Asia Pacific turned over about A$100m a year, sold around 2,500 forklifts and was losing about A$100,000 at the EBIT line, because machines were being sold below cost. Reps could offer discounts at will, and the business had no controls or plan to manage pricing strategy.
ChallengeReps were paid on volume and discounted harder to make the monthly budget. The business ran through a dealer network much like a car dealership, where dealers earn more on used units, hire, service and parts than on new machines, and one dealer cited price as the constant reason for lost sales while its sales approach reached only price buyers.
What Pricing Insight didProject Blackbird price optimisation. Every forklift sale crossed one dealing desk, run by the pricing manager, and was tested against competitors, customer type, finance and lease terms. Discounts were limited on the 5 to 7 tonne machines, which carried pricing power in timber and steel where equipment failure is costly, and allowed on low-power models to build the dealers’ installed base; accessories and parts were repriced, an electronic price list and quote tool replaced manual keying, and parts staff no longer saw cost.
OutcomeFrom a A$100k EBIT loss to a A$3m EBIT gain within 12 months, a realised result as published.
Benefit to the clientA loss-making business returned to profit at the operating line within a year without a new product or a cost program, and every discount on a new machine now carried a reason the pricing manager had checked.
Periodic Table elements built40 Dd Deal desk and negotiation governance; 61 Da Discount authority and controls; 10 Pp Pricing power; 58 Qt Quoting speed and tools.

Arnott’s had the same problem in a different form. The concessions were promotional promises to retailers rather than discounts on a list price, and nobody above the account manager saw them until the margin had gone.

02

Arnott’s

Biscuit maker · Over A$5m EBIT recovered in 12 months · Realised

Client and problemArnott’s 41 account managers were making promotional promises to retailers that nobody tracked, so promotional funding and channel terms moved margin without anyone seeing what each promotion returned.
ChallengeEach account manager held the account’s commitments individually, and channel conflict meant a price set for one channel affected another, so there was no single view of which promotions paid.
What Pricing Insight didPricing was centralised in a pricing team, promotional return was modelled for 100 SKUs, channel conflict was resolved and execution was reshaped across the 41 account managers.
OutcomeOver A$5m of EBIT recovered in 12 months on a A$100m base, a realised result.
Benefit to the clientEBIT equal to about 5 per cent of the revenue base came back within a year, and every promotion now runs through one team that can see its cost and its return, which lowers the exposure to concessions made account by account with no record.
Periodic Table elements built26 Pf Pricing function mandate; 46 Pm Price modelling; 08 Sg Segment and channel strategy; 16 Rb Rebate and incentive design.

03Discounts keep a place in the strategy when each one has a rationale and is reported

Price flexibility

Note that Musk does not state that discounting has no role to play in the Tesla business model. Rather, he makes it clear that pricing dynamically to reflect value is important, and as long as discounts have some context, are controlled, and are connected to a clear set of value drivers, they play a part in the pricing strategy / management mix.

Analysis and control

In this email, it is also apparent that all discounts will be evaluated and controls implemented with Finance to make all pricing decisions transparent and accountable.

Four questions turn that principle into a test a deal desk can apply to each request. They come from the criteria the Hyster-Yale dealing desk used on every forklift sale, and from the evidence of what goes wrong when no one asks them.

Question before a discount is approvedWhat a good answer looks likeWhat a weak answer usually means
Is price really the issue?The customer has compared a like-for-like offer, including service, support and reliabilityThe rep is matching a competitor’s claimed price without knowing what that price buys
Does this product carry pricing power?The product is one where the customer’s cost of failure is high, so the discount is held backThe same discount is offered across the range
What does the customer give in return?Volume, term, a share of spend or an ordering pattern that lowers cost to serveNothing measurable; the discount rewards the request
Could this be explained to a full-price customer?Yes, in one sentence about volume, cost or valueNo, which is Musk’s acid test failing

Exhibit 2. A four-question test for the deal desk. Questions drawn from the Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific case study (dealing desk criteria and the advice to be sure price is the issue before discounting) and from Exhibit 1.

Approval rules work only if there is no route around them. At Allegion the route was simple: a request to change a price, made to the right person, was enough.

03

Allegion

Door locks and lever handles · A$3.8m to A$6.5m EBIT gain · Identified

Client and problemKey ranges had gone years without a general increase while inflation and the exchange rate moved against the business. Revenue targets were being met while gross margin dollars were missed, and some ranges sold at little or no margin.
ChallengeA 2019 acquisition merged four price structures mechanically into one ERP with data errors, layered discounts on list prices few staff or customers understood, and left no dedicated pricing role. Price files sat on a shared drive with no owners or review rhythm, and approval limits leaked; in a staff member’s words, “some people just ask for a price to be changed and it happens. No financial rationale or approvals needed.”
What Pricing Insight didA pricing diagnostic and quick wins that built governance, trained teams and reset deal discipline across channels. The recommendation put the organisation first: authority limits, named owners for price lists, a fortnightly pricing review and a simpler discount structure of three to five levels, the structure staff had proposed.
OutcomeAn A$3.8m to A$6.5m EBIT gain identified, as published. Identified, not realised.
Benefit to the clientA leaking approval route, a deferred increase and an unowned price file sized as one EBIT range, with owners and a review date in place before prices move, which reduces the exposure to discounts given with no rationale.
Periodic Table elements built22 Rs Roles and decision rights; 61 Da Discount authority and controls; 27 Rc Review cadence; 51 Dt Discount structure and tiers.

04A no-negotiation policy holds only when value has been made clear before the meeting

All customers want a deal. All sales people want to make a deal happen. It feels good to negotiate. It sounds as though we have an aggressive culture of successful salesmanship when we say that “we negotiate hard”. But what is actually happening here? A customer demands a price reduction when the product appears to be commoditised, the value of services and technical support is discounted to zero, and there is no accountability on the buyer’s part to own the outcome of purchasing inferior product and service package.

This is a fundamentally different problem that negotiation cannot solve. This is a marketing value communication problem.

Number one sales challenge

In fact, the Number One challenge all sales people face today is ensuring that their marketing strategy positions their company, brands, and products or services as being able to solve the specific problems identified by a “customer segment of one”. In simple terms, showing up to a sales meeting to negotiate without first ensuring that all the elements of a high-value sale are in place will result in a price negotiation.

Devro faced imported product at up to half its price. It held and raised price by doing the value work first and planning the increase last.

04

Devro

Food manufacturing · Higher price increases negotiated in Australia and New Zealand · Realised

Client and problemDevro makes collagen casings for sausages and sells to food manufacturers that use competing quotes and push for price cuts at each contract round. Cheaper imported casings arrived in Australia and New Zealand, some offered at up to half of Devro’s price, and on a price-per-metre comparison Devro looked expensive.
ChallengeMuch of what Devro supplied never appeared on the invoice: line support, consistent casing performance, local supply, food safety certification and contract price stability. Customers rated most value drivers as more important than Devro’s own team did, so the business was giving away value it did not know it had.
What Pricing Insight didCustomer Value Discovery across 21 value drivers in six categories, scored by customers and by Devro’s team against the main competitor. The evidence fed a sample supply agreement for a key account and a production audit tool that measures yield on the customer’s own line, and the price increase was planned last, once the value case was in place.
OutcomeHigher price increases negotiated in Australia and New Zealand, a realised result as published, not quantified in dollars. Devro’s Sales Director, Australia and New Zealand: “Undertaking the Customer Value Discovery program helped us identify additional sources of value and allowed DEVRO to negotiate higher price increases both in Australia and New Zealand.”
Benefit to the clientPrice held and raised against rivals up to 50 per cent cheaper, with lead time, local supply and continuity written into the agreement rather than argued afresh at each round, which lowers Devro’s exposure to a price match.
Periodic Table elements built03 Vq Value quantification; 04 Sv Service value; 29 Vs Value selling; 38 Pv Price-increase negotiation.

05Policy, guidelines and system controls make a pricing strategy effective

Pricing is your most powerful profit lever. If pricing is not a primary concern of the CEO, the business has a major problem. There must be a set of policies and guidelines backed up by system controls to make any pricing strategy or policy effective.

If your value proposition is not clear to each market segment, you have a pricing strategy problem and, without a doubt, a margin erosion problem.

Three things are safe to read from the four cases. Speed: at Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific and Arnott’s the result came within 12 months, and in both the change was who controls a price below list, not a new product or a cost program. Size: the realised results are a swing from a A$100k EBIT loss to a A$3m gain at Hyster-Yale and over A$5m of EBIT at Arnott’s, and the identified opportunity at Allegion is A$3.8m to A$6.5m of EBIT. Risk: each case closed a route by which margin left without a decision, whether discounts at will, untracked promotional promises, price changes made on request or a value case left unstated in the negotiation. Identified opportunities are not results, and none of these figures is a benchmark for another business.

06The Pricing Periodic Table elements this paper builds

The Pricing Periodic Table sets out 61 elements of pricing capability in nine domains, across Value, People and Structures. Seven are built by the approach in this paper: 20 Ed Executive direction (the chief executive owns pricing strategy and reviews outcomes), 13 Py Pricing policy (no discount without a rationale), 61 Da Discount authority and controls (no customer exempt by relationship), 40 Dd Deal desk and negotiation governance (one point that sees every price below list), 44 Or Override and discount analysis (finance reports every sale below list with its reason), 48 Kp Price realisation KPIs (the measure the chief executive reads) and 29 Vs Value selling (value made clear before the negotiation). Five are depended on: 01 Vp Value proposition must be clear to each segment, 08 Sg Segment and channel strategy decides where a discount has a place, 54 Co Price corridors and exceptions gives the acid test its numbers, 33 In Sales incentives decides what a rep feels when a discount is given, and 59 Is Integrated pricing systems enforces the rules at quote and order entry.

The client cases map onto these elements directly. Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific built 40 Dd and 61 Da through a single dealing desk, the forklift version of Musk’s personal review. Arnott’s built 26 Pf and 46 Pm by moving promotional decisions from 41 account managers to one pricing team. Allegion closed a gap in 61 Da where a price could be changed with no rationale. Devro built 29 Vs and 03 Vq, which is what lets a supplier decline to negotiate on price at all.

Pricing Periodic Table of 61 elements with 7 elements highlighted in gold and 5 outlined for the paper How to Make Tesla’s Pricing Strategy Work For Your Business
Figure 1. Gold: 20 Ed Executive direction, 13 Py Pricing policy, 61 Da Discount authority and controls, 40 Dd Deal desk and negotiation governance, 44 Or Override and discount analysis, 48 Kp Price realisation KPIs, 29 Vs Value selling. Outlined: 01 Vp, 08 Sg, 54 Co, 33 In, 59 Is.

07Frequently asked questions

How do I stop sales reps over-discounting in a B2B business?

Require a stated reason for every discount, from a short approved list, and route every price below a set floor through one approver. Report every sale below list each month by product, rep and customer, and have the chief executive read it. Pay that rewards margin as well as volume makes the rep feel part of the cost. Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific moved from a A$100k EBIT loss to a A$3m EBIT gain within 12 months after one dealing desk replaced discounts given at will, a realised result.

How do I set up pricing governance and discount approval rules?

Name who owns each price list, set authority bands by role and margin with a named approver for each band, and close every route around them, including price changes made on request. Review the bands and the override report on a fixed cycle through a pricing council. At Allegion, where a price could be changed with no financial rationale or approval, the recommended governance sat behind an identified A$3.8m to A$6.5m EBIT gain.

My margins are shrinking. What should I do about pricing?

Find where margin leaves the business before changing any price: discounts with no rationale, concessions nobody tracks, prices below list with no approval, and value given away in negotiation. Size each in EBIT and fix the largest first. At Arnott’s, centralising pricing and modelling the return on promotions recovered over A$5m of EBIT in 12 months on a A$100m base, a realised result.

Should the chief executive be involved in pricing decisions?

Yes, in the strategy and the outcomes, not in each quote. The chief executive sets the pricing policy, decides who holds discount authority and reads a monthly report of every sale below list with its reason. That is the role Musk describes in his email, and it is the role a pricing council supports in a business-to-business company.

Can a business-to-business company run a no-discount policy like Tesla’s?

Most cannot remove discounts entirely, because volume, term and cost to serve differ between customers. What transfers is the rule: no discount without a rationale that could be explained to a customer who paid full price. Devro shows the other half of the policy: by proving value first, it negotiated higher price increases in Australia and New Zealand against imports offered at up to half its price, a realised result.

08How Pricing Insight helps

The paper’s emphasis on CEO oversight, transparent discount decisions and clear exceptions calls for pricing rules that sales and finance can apply consistently across the business. Pricing Capability & Governance sets pricing roles, decision rights, discount approvals and price floors, and establishes a Pricing Council to make the controls behind a disciplined pricing approach clear and sustained.

The work runs in three stages, each drawing on evidence from the client’s own transactions. Pricing Insight has completed 160+ engagements, and price optimisation programs return between 5 and 10 times their cost in year 1.

1

Diagnose

Twelve months of invoices by rep, customer and product through the Strategic EBIT Opportunity & Risk Diagnostic. Every sale below list, the reason recorded for it, the routes around approval and the value customers receive but do not pay for, sized against a baseline finance accepts.

2

Optimise

Target prices, price floors and corridors by product and segment through the EBITDA Improvement Program, with an approved list of discount reasons and authority bands measured from those prices, delivered as ERP-ready files.

3

Transform

Decision rights, a deal desk and a Pricing Council through Pricing Capability & Governance, and sellers trained to make value clear before price is discussed through Negotiation Training & Value-Based Selling. The override report goes into the monthly pack the chief executive reads.

How many of last month’s discounts could your team explain to a customer who paid full price?

A first conversation establishes how this applies in your business and whether a diagnostic is warranted. Ron Wood, +61 410 534 099.

Contact Pricing Insight
About the author

Ron Wood is the Founder and Managing Director of Pricing Insight, an Australian pricing strategy consultancy he established in 2007. He has worked in pricing for 30 years, first as a pricing and commercial manager in consumer goods, building materials and capital equipment, and since then across 160+ engagements in Australia, New Zealand, South East Asia, India, the United States and the United Kingdom. He also founded Pricing University and is the author of the Pricing Periodic Table, CXO Edition.

To discuss discount controls and pricing governance in your business, contact Ron Wood at info@pricinginsight.com.au or on +61 410 534 099, or visit Pricing Insight.

The Tesla email is reproduced as published; the $30 billion figure and the reference to General Electric are public reporting at the time the paper was first written. Hyster-Yale Asia Pacific, Arnott’s and Devro results are realised as published in Pricing Insight case studies; the Devro result is not quantified in dollars, and its quote is attributed by job title. The Allegion figure is an identified opportunity, not a result, and the Allegion staff comment comes from Pricing Insight diagnostic work and is attributed by role only. Exhibits 1 and 2 are Pricing Insight’s interpretation, not client results. Results are as reported by Pricing Insight and have not been independently audited. No figure in this paper is typical or guaranteed.

Let’s work together

Whether you're ready to optimise your pricing or want to explore what's possible, we'd love to hear from you.

Follow us on
Pricing Insight

Thank you

Thanks for reaching out. We will get back to you soon.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Pricing Insight